Skip to content
Auto Insurance Index

Methodology

How the index is built

Public sources, checked against what they publish themselves, turned into bands and ranges. Every number names its source and year. November 2026 edition, data as of 2026-11-14.

Ranges below the state level

State and national figures are published exactly, with their source and year. Everything below the state level is a range: a county is “$1,400–$1,600,” never a single dollar figure, and a ZIP code is a band on the map. That's deliberate.

  • A range is honest about what the data can say. Survey estimates for one county carry real margins of error, and a range doesn't pretend otherwise.
  • The exact figures for your own area, and where your own policy ranks among drivers near you, live at What My Neighbors Pay. They open up when you share what you pay. The public tables behind them are linked below; what you unlock is our cleaning and adjustments, the exact figures, the regulator comparison, and figures from neighbors who shared what they pay.
  • Rates people share with What My Neighbors Pay are never published here at ZIP level, and never as exact figures below the state level.

Each build runs an automated check that fails if any figure finer than a range appears on a county or ZIP page.

The color bands

Each map layer has seven bands with round-number breaks, set once in our data pipeline for the whole country so colors compare from coast to coast. The breaks are chosen to follow where people live (weighted by homeowners or policies, not by how many small counties there are) and to spread out the top end, where costs are changing fastest. Every county and ZIP gets the band its value falls in, from the same source everywhere. The legend shows each band's range, so color is never the only signal. Counties without a reliable value are hatched.

Average premium per insured car, per year
  1. Under $1,050
  2. $1,050–$1,100
  3. $1,100–$1,150
  4. $1,150–$1,200
  5. $1,200–$1,250
  6. $1,250–$1,350
  7. $1,350 or more
  8. Not enough data yet

California Department of Insurance, 2023. Other states don't publish local auto prices yet.

Official averages as ranges

Where a regulator publishes a county average, we show it on a fixed grid: $100-wide ranges under $1,000, $250-wide under $2,000, and $500-wide above that. Changes over time appear as coarse directions (“up 25%–50% since 2020”).

Shares and rates

Nonrenewal rates appear as ranges: under 0.5%, 0.5%–1%, 1%–2%, 2%–3%, 3%–5%, 5%–10%, 10%–20%, and 20% or more.

The headline figure

Each state's headline is the regulator's own average premium per insured car, where one exists. Most states publish none, so most of the map starts empty and fills in from rates drivers share at What My Neighbors Pay.

Sample sizes and margins of error

Regulator averages cover every insured car that insurers report to the state, so they aren't samples. Rates drivers share are, and a county shows a figure from them only once enough drivers have shared. Until then it stays hatched.

How we grade states

We reviewed what every state's insurance regulator publishes about car insurance prices (November 2026):

  • A: average premiums by county, ZIP or rating territory, in a form we can load.
  • B: company-by-company sample-rate guides, or local averages only inside a PDF.
  • C: statewide averages only.
  • D: nothing useful.

This edition: 1 states graded A, 18 states graded B, 3 states graded C, 29 states graded D.

Which pages are indexed

A county page is offered to search engines only when it has at least two data layers that pass the margin-of-error check. Thinner pages still exist for people, marked noindex.

Sources and caveats

  1. California Department of Insurance, Private Passenger Automobile Insurance Report

    State, county

    Earned premium per insured car-year, all coverages, by county. The colors on the auto map.

    • Per insured car-year: CDI's exposure counts car-months, divided by 12.
    • Standard and non-standard programs combined.
    • Data through 2023.

    Source: California Department of Insurance. Not endorsed by CDI.

  2. Missouri Department of Commerce and Insurance, Private Passenger Automobile Report

    State, county

    Average liability premium per car-year by county.

    • Liability coverage only, so it's well below a full policy's cost.

    Source: Missouri Department of Commerce and Insurance. Not endorsed by DCI.

  3. Texas Department of Insurance, HB 2067 data

    State, county

    Auto nonrenewals, cancellations and declinations, and insured vehicles.

    • Counts over three months; no prices.

    Source: Texas Department of Insurance (Texas Statistical Plan for Residential Risks; HB 2067 data on data.texas.gov).

House rules

  • Code computes every number. Words are written around them.
  • No savings promises and no carrier rankings.
  • Carrier names appear only with a regulator's own figures. Shared rates are never broken out by carrier.
  • We never sell data, and we never publish an address, a household, a driver or a policy.

Who runs this

What My Neighbors Pay, which publishes this index, is run by MicroEndeavor LLC. The index is free, and we never sell your data or share it with anyone unless you ask. The index is not an insurance company, and it never names a company to buy from.

Updates and corrections

The index is rebuilt when the data pipeline runs (monthly) and frozen as a press edition each quarter. Map data as of 2023. Spotted an error? Tell us through What My Neighbors Pay.